Cocktails pairings for Aged Cheddar

Old Fashioned

5 dishes

Bourbon & American whiskey

Bourbon or rye, sugar, bitters, orange.

Why it works

Mid-bodied, soft-sweet, citrus-bright pours flex with everything from roast bird to fried wings.

Works with Aged Cheddar · Bandaged Cheddar · Aged Cheddar Burger · Aged Cheddar Cheese +1 more Aged Cheddar · Bandaged Cheddar · Aged Cheddar Burger · Aged Cheddar Cheese · Chicken Stuffed With Aged Cheddar And Prosciutto

Shop bottles Value pick Discover more

Boulevardier

4 dishes

Classic & stirred

Bourbon, Campari, sweet vermouth. The whiskey Negroni — richer, less bitter.

Why it works

Hop-cut and oak-sweet pours scrub fat and stand up to charred beef and melted cheese.

Works with Aged Cheddar · Bandaged Cheddar · Aged Cheddar Burger · Aged Cheddar Cheese

Shop bottles Value pick Discover more

Manhattan

4 dishes

Classic & stirred

Rye, sweet vermouth, bitters, brandied cherry. The quintessential brown-spirit cocktail.

Why it works

Hop-cut and oak-sweet pours scrub fat and stand up to charred beef and melted cheese.

Works with Aged Cheddar · Bandaged Cheddar · Aged Cheddar Burger · Aged Cheddar Cheese

Shop bottles Value pick Discover more

Sidecar

4 dishes

Shaken sours

Cognac, lemon, orange liqueur. Old-world elegance in a coupe.

Why it works

Caramel, oak, and dried-fruit notes echo aged cheese's nutty-crystalline depth.

Works with Aged Cheddar · Bandaged Cheddar · Aged Cheddar Burger · Aged Cheddar Cheese

Shop bottles Value pick Discover more

Aperol Spritz

2 dishes

Aperitivo & low-ABV

Aperol, Prosecco, soda water, orange slice. Sunset orange — Italian summer.

Why it works

Citrus-bright, lightly bitter, or aged-sweet pours all flex with mozzarella, parmesan, and the in-between.

Works with Aged Cheddar Cheese · Chicken Stuffed With Aged Cheddar And Prosciutto

Shop bottles Value pick Discover more

Classic Martini

2 dishes

Vodka & gin

Bone-dry, crisp, olive-edged.

Why it works

Mid-bodied, soft-sweet, citrus-bright pours flex with everything from roast bird to fried wings.

Works with Aged Cheddar Cheese · Chicken Stuffed With Aged Cheddar And Prosciutto

Shop bottles Value pick Discover more

Negroni

2 dishes

Vodka & gin

Bittersweet, herbal, the aperitivo standard.

Why it works

Aperitivo-style pours — bitter, citrus-driven, low-to-mid proof — were invented for cured-meat platters.

Works with Aged Cheddar Cheese · Chicken Stuffed With Aged Cheddar And Prosciutto

Shop bottles Value pick Discover more

Campari Soda

Aperitivo & low-ABV

Campari, soda water, orange. Bitter, low-proof, conversation-starting.

Why it works with Chicken Stuffed With Aged Cheddar And Prosciutto

Aperitivo-style pours — bitter, citrus-driven, low-to-mid proof — were invented for cured-meat platters.

Shop bottles Value pick Discover more

Hugo Spritz

Aperitivo & low-ABV

Elderflower liqueur, Prosecco, mint, soda. The Negronis softer cousin.

Why it works with Chicken Stuffed With Aged Cheddar And Prosciutto

Aperitivo-style pours — bitter, citrus-driven, low-to-mid proof — were invented for cured-meat platters.

Shop bottles Value pick Discover more

Whiskey Sour

Shaken sours

Bourbon, fresh lemon, sugar, optional egg-white foam.

Why it works with Aged Cheddar Burger

Hop-cut and oak-sweet pours scrub fat and stand up to charred beef and melted cheese.

Shop bottles Value pick Discover more